Prescription Heroin for Heroin Addiction Treatment?
Monday, July 13th, 2009Um… what? Though I’m pretty sure that in England it is actually legal to prescribe heroin in certain cases of pain management, I’m not sure how often that actually happens (do they prescribe clean needles, too? And cookers? What about cottons and clean waters?) And where that seems counterintuitive considering the worldwide problem that is heroin addiction, starting with the nature of the business of heroin production, is apparently under consideration in Canada. It seems our neighbor to the north is considering prescribing heroin to treat heroin addiction.
There Was a Three-Year Study on Heroin Prescription for Heroin Addiction Treatment
Yes, a three-year, government-funded study on the efficacy of prescribing pharmaceutical grade heroin to heroin addicts. The results are being called “remarkable.”
Dr. Martin Schechter was the North American Opiate Medication Initiative, or NAOMI, principal investigator in the study. He says, “Heroin-assisted treatment (HAT) is very safe when done properly. Our results show it to be very effective.”
The Argument Against Heroin Prescription for Heroin Addiction Treatment
Well, can you really predict the outcome of fighting fire with fire? And then there’s the idea that it’s a step toward legalizing the drug, which many are against. Many simply don’t like the idea that their tax dollars would go to maintain a heroin addicts addiction even though far more tax dollars are spent cleaning up the damage caused by heroin addiction. Still others argue against heroin addiction clinics and the like for the same reason that they don’t want methadone clinics in their neighborhood. There’s also the idea that acknowledging the problem somehow condones it.
The Argument For Heroin Prescription for Heroin Addiction Treatment
Why not? For many who have repeatedly tried and failed to kick using the more traditional methods, this could work. And if the goal isn’t necessarily abstinence but harm reduction, it certainly is a lot less expensive to provide this kind of regular upkeep and treatment—ostensibly, maintaining someone’s addiction—rather than pay for the damage due to criminal activity or the medical bills of the uninsured who overdose on non-pharmaceutical grade heroin in the street.
Then there’s the argument of quality of living. When you’re strung out on heroin, your entire focus is on your next dose. When you regulate your addiction and get it under control with methadone or, like this research shows, with three regular doses of heroin each day, then you are free to think about other things. People who never have before were getting and holding down part time jobs while on this study. They were having viable and functioning friendships and relationships with other people that didn’t center around heroin addiction. It seemed to function much like methadone in freeing the person from their mental—if not physical and emotional—attachment to their addiction.
What Do You Think of Heroin for Heroin Addiction Treatment?
Do you think it’s on the same par as methadone? Or do you think that it doesn’t make sense at all?




